News

Property Disputes After Separation Should Not Be a Legal Lottery

‹ News

Property Disputes After Separation Should Not Be a Legal Lottery

At the beginning of a relationship, couples rarely think about recovering expenses from one another. They contribute to a shared home and family life, believing they are building a future together. When love comes to an end, however, spreadsheets, bank statements and old invoices may come out, and a dispute over property begins. Increasingly, the concept of a partnership comes into play in place of the relationship itself, shifting the boundaries both in time and in law. RASK Attorney-at-Law and Co-Head of the Family Law, Inheritance and Succession practice Kai Villemson and Lawyer Laura Helena Koppel explain why applying partnership provisions to property disputes between unmarried couples raises legal difficulties and whether Estonia needs a clearer regulatory framework.

Applying the provisions on the liquidation of a partnership to the division of property is becoming an increasingly common legal strategy. This approach may be particularly attractive following the end of a long-term relationship, when other claims for compensation have already become time-barred. Although reliance on the analogous application of partnership provisions is becoming more common in property disputes between unmarried couples, its legal boundaries remain unclear.

A Partnership the Parties May Never Have Intended to Establish


Estonian law does not provide unmarried couples with a clear statutory framework comparable to the rules governing joint property under the community of property regime applicable to married couples. For example, immovable property generally belongs to the person registered as its owner in the land register, while ownership of immovable property held in common ownership is determined by the respective ownership shares. The Supreme Court has held that the fact that a property was used as a shared home or paid for jointly does not, in itself, make both partners its owners.

A partnership, by contrast, is a contractual form of cooperation that requires the parties to act towards a common objective, and registration of ownership in the land register does not preclude a claim for compensation. Accordingly, even where immovable property is not registered in both partners' names, this does not necessarily prevent the other partner from seeking compensation.

It is therefore understandable why parties may wish to rely on partnership provisions when resolving property disputes. While claims for reimbursement of ordinary expenses incurred earlier in a long-term relationship may already be time-barred by the time the relationship ends, a claim based on the analogous application of the provisions on the liquidation of a partnership may still be brought years later, even in the absence of a specific agreement.

According to the case law of the Supreme Court, partnership provisions may be applied where (i) an asset of substantial value was acquired during the relationship, (ii) the parties made significant and comparable financial contributions towards acquiring or improving that asset, and (iii) the parties shared an intention to create joint economic value.

However, it is precisely in interpreting these seemingly clear conditions that difficulties arise, often making the outcome of a dispute hard to predict.

How Comparable Must “Comparable” Contributions Be?


On the one hand, contributions do not have to be equal. On the other, it is not sufficient for both parties merely to have incurred some expenses.
In case law, contributions of approximately 30% and 70% towards the costs of constructing a residential building have been considered comparable, whereas contributions of approximately 6% and 94% have not. The only clear principle is that comparability does not mean equality.

What remains unclear is how substantial the difference between the parties' contributions may be before they can no longer be regarded as comparable. Would a contribution of 20% by one party be sufficient? How should financial expenditure be compared with construction work carried out by the other partner?

An even more difficult question is which expenses can be regarded as relevant contributions in the first place. Case law is not consistent on this issue.

The Supreme Court has emphasised that a contribution capable of monetary valuation may include, for example, an initial payment towards the acquisition of property, whereas merely covering ongoing expenses is insufficient.

At the same time, courts have found that even renovation work on immovable property does not necessarily constitute a contribution indicative of a partnership. Ordinary repairs and maintenance may also be regarded as expenses incurred to meet the everyday needs of family life and do not necessarily involve the creation of lasting economic value.

The distinction between ordinary household expenses and partnership-like economic activity therefore remains unclear.

Does Establishing a Shared Home Demonstrate a Common Intention to Create Economic Value?


In addition, the court must establish that the parties shared an intention to create lasting joint economic value. What matters is not only what the parties did, but also the purpose behind their actions.

Establishing a shared home inevitably has economic consequences. At the same time, the parties' actual objective may have been primarily family-related: to create a home for themselves and their children.

The difficulty lies in the fact that family-related and economic objectives may be inseparably intertwined in practice, making them difficult to distinguish. Nor has case law established a clear distinction between them.

Some judges have considered the acquisition of a shared home and taking out a loan for that purpose to constitute an economic interest. Others have regarded these activities as a natural, non-economic aspect of family life.

The less consistent the case law, the more difficult it becomes to assess the prospects of potential litigation.

Fair Compensation or an Unexpected Share of the Property's Value?


When the provisions on the liquidation of a partnership are applied, it is not the property itself, such as immovable property, that is divided, but rather the value created through the parties' contributions.

To determine that value, the property's actual value at the time of division must be compared with its hypothetical value at the same point in time had the joint contributions not been made.

For example, if a property was purchased for EUR 100,000 and its value has increased to EUR 250,000 by the end of the relationship, this does not automatically mean that the parties have jointly created EUR 150,000 in value.

Part of the increase may be attributable to general appreciation in the real estate market or changes in the value of the location, neither of which is connected to the parties' contributions.

At the same time, the overall increase in market value cannot be disregarded entirely if the parties have made permanent improvements to the property whose value has also increased alongside the wider market.

In practice, this means that an expert assessment is generally required not only of the existing property but also of a hypothetical version of the property that does not actually exist.

In other words, what would the property's current market value be if the extension, renovation or other improvements had never been carried out?

Is There a Better Alternative?


Existing case law raises the question of whether a clearer legal framework could be developed for resolving property disputes between unmarried couples.

The purpose of applying the provisions on the liquidation of a partnership by analogy is to prevent one partner from obtaining an unjustified financial benefit at the expense of the other's substantial contributions.

However, achieving this objective is complicated by the fact that partnership provisions were designed to regulate contractual economic cooperation rather than family relationships.

Any potential special regulation must nevertheless recognise that unmarried cohabitation is not equivalent to marriage in terms of property rights.

Unmarried couples must retain the freedom to decide whether they wish to assume the legal consequences associated with marriage.

The solution should therefore not be to extend the rules governing the division of matrimonial property to unmarried couples, but rather to establish a clearly defined claim for compensation that would protect against unjustified financial advantages.

Finland, for example, has regulated the property relations of unmarried couples since 2011 through separate legislation governing the dissolution of the household of cohabiting partners. As a general rule, the legislation applies to couples who have lived together for at least five years or who have a child together.

The legislation does not convert their property into joint property, but it allows a partner to claim compensation where their contribution to the shared household has helped the other partner acquire or increase their property.

Relevant contributions may include work carried out for the benefit of the shared household or the other partner's property, payment of shared expenses, and direct financial investments in the other partner's property.

Unlike under Estonian case law, there is no requirement to demonstrate that the parties made comparable contributions or shared an intention to create lasting economic value.

Sweden has adopted a different approach. Under its legislation governing unmarried cohabiting partners, a home acquired for joint use is subject to division when the relationship ends, even if only one partner contributed towards its acquisition.

As a general rule, the value of the property is divided equally, regardless of the size of the parties' respective contributions, and the legislation does not require the relationship to have lasted for any particular period.

The Finnish and Swedish approaches do not offer Estonia a ready-made solution. They do, however, demonstrate that protecting the property interests of unmarried couples does not necessarily require reliance on the analogous application of partnership provisions.

Estonia could consider introducing an independent claim for compensation based on one partner's contribution to increasing or preserving the value of property, without extending the property division rules applicable to married couples to unmarried relationships.

Love does not have to begin with an agreement on how property will be divided. But neither should its end leave the parties in a situation where even a legally justified outcome is almost impossible to predict.

Existing case law needs clearer boundaries: which contributions should be taken into account, when can they be considered comparable, and how should a family-related objective be distinguished from a shared intention to create economic value?

Greater clarity on these questions would help ensure fairer outcomes and enable parties to assess the prospects of a dispute more accurately before initiating court proceedings.